This House Had Two HVAC Systems… But the Master Bedroom Felt Like an Oven

Learn more at homeairleakagetest.com
Watch this stuff on YouTube

Transcript

 It was one of those classic Maryland summer days where the second you step outside of your house, your glasses fog up if you wear 'em, and your shirt doesn't take long to start sticking to your back. And honestly, when I walked into this house for an energy audit that day, it didn't feel a whole lot different inside. The homeowner, Nellie Dark, she'd called me because her upstairs master bedroom was brutal in the summer. They'd been living there for a few years, and each year it was getting hotter, it seemed, and stickier, more uncomfortable. And what really made this situation interesting is that they'd spent serious money trying to fix it. In fact, during a recent remodel, they actually added a second HVAC system to the upstairs, a second zone, and they thought, "Okay, this has to solve the problem." Surprise, it didn't. The bedroom, it still felt like an oven. Meanwhile, the basement was freezing cold. It seemed like they were getting a lot more bugs than before, and the house overall, it just felt off to them. It was like things were just fighting against themselves. And this is the part that fascinates me, because this exact story I know, it's happening all over across America, all over the place right now. Homeowners are spending thousands, sometimes even tens of thousands of dollars trying to solve comfort problems without really ever being told why the house is behaving that way in the first place. And when I started digging into this particular house, what I found explained pretty much everything, because the real problem was not the HVAC system. The house, it was working against itself One of the biggest problems homeowners have right now it's not a lack of products. It's not a lack of contractors. It's confusion. Everybody is telling them something different One guy says you need a bigger HVAC. The other guy is saying it's your windows. Somebody online says that spray foam fixes everything, and then somebody else is telling you no, your house, needs to breathe." And meanwhile, you, the homeowner, you're just standing there, and you're in the middle of all this, and all you really want is just a nice, cool, comfortable house so that you can get some sleep every night. That's why I wanted to start this podcast because after doing hundreds and hundreds of energy audits, I started realizing that most people, they're never really taught how their house works, and I know because I was one of them. Nobody explains the system. Nobody explains why the upstairs is getting so hot, and nobody's explaining why the basement feels so cold. Nobody's even telling you why one room is so freaking hot and the other one is freezing cold. And honestly, once you understand the why behind some of this stuff, things really start to make logical sense. That's really the backbone of this entire show. Most home comfort problems, they're not HVAC problems, not window problems. They're usually building science problems and insulation problems So Nellie, she started walking me through the house, and within probably the first two minutes, I could already tell this wasn't gonna be a simple replace a part and move on kind of situation. She's explaining how uncomfortable the upstairs gets during the summer, especially as the day progresses. And I remember her saying something alongs a line- something along the lines of, "We thought adding a second system would finally solve the problem." But then she kinda laughed in that sort of like frustrated homeowner voice, and she said, "Honestly, it still feels hot up here all the time." And I hear that all the time because most homeowners assume that if they add more cooling, the problem is just gonna go away. They get a bigger system, they get a new system, and that's just simply not the case. It sounds logical, but houses are systems, and buildings have envelopes. And if the envelope is working against you, then the HVAC equipment ends up fighting a losing battle So now we started talking about how the basement is freezing while the upstairs is roasting, and immediately I'm thinking, "Okay this has a problem. This house has a big stratification problem. This house is stratifying badly." And then they mentioned the bugs getting inside, and it sounds unrelated at first, but in my world, bugs, drafts, humidity, temperature imbalance, these are all often signs and clues pointing to the same larger problem. The house is leaking air Now, if you ask most homeowners what causes a hot upstairs, the answers are pretty much the same and predictable. The AC is too small. I need another zone. The windows are bad. The upstairs system can't keep up. The air isn't traveling through the duct system and getting to the furthest points. And honestly, I really understand why people think that, because the HVAC system is the thing they can see. It's the thing that makes noise. It's the thing that blows the cold air. But one of the biggest mindset sh- but one of the biggest mindset shifts in building science is realizing that HVAC equipment does not create comfort alone The house has to help the HVAC system. I always explain it like trying to cool your backyard. You can put the world's biggest air conditioner out there outside. You can put the world's biggest air conditioner outside, but if there's no enclosure holding that conditioned air where you want it, you're just gonna be fighting physics all day long, and that's exactly what is happening here So we start making our way through the house, and one of the things I always tell homeowners during the audit is your house leaves clues everywhere. You just have to know how to read them. So the upstairs did feel heavy and warm while I was there, as I mentioned. The basement was cooler and clammy. Certain rooms did feel stagnant. I checked airflow. I looked at the insulation levels. I was looking for any type of bypasses, disconnected pressure boundaries, disconnected ductwork. And once I got into the attic, things started making a lot of sense because attics are really where the houses start to truly confess their sins. That's where all the shortcuts are found, all the gaps, all the things nobody's sealed. And what homeowners don't realize is that your attic is basically outside. It is outside of your envelope. It's covered by a roof, but it's still technically outside of your house. It's not part of your conditioned living space. So every little opening between the house and the attic is a pathway for heat, humidity, and air leakage. And this house, it had a lot of pathways What we eventually discovered was that the house had a ma-- What we eventually-- What I eventually discovered was that the h- what I eventually discovered is that the house had major air leakage pathways connecting the living space to the attic, as I suspected. Openings around penetrations, there were unsealed transitions in areas where insulation wasn't even in contact with the drywall surface. This is one of the biggest misconceptions that homeowners have about insulation. Insulation does not stop air movement. It slows heat transfer. It's a different thing. So if air is freely moving around the insulation is not gonna be able to perform the way that people thinks-- the way that people think that it will. I always-- I like to explain it like wearing a winter coat with a zipper wide open. The insulation in the coat, it, it exists. It's there. It's gonna keep you a little bit warmer than if you had none at all. However, when the zipper is wide open, the air movement destroys the insulation's effectiveness. It's not nearly as effective as if it's buttoned up and zipped up nice and tight, and that's what's happening throughout this house. So now the upstairs HVAC system is trying to cool rooms while the house is simultaneously pulling heat and humidity into the structure through the stack effect. Physics. Building science. The HVAC, it wasn't broken. The house was overpowering it. One of the most important concepts homeowners can understand is something called the stack effect, and honestly, once you get a grasp on it, houses, they start behaving way less mysteriously We're all taught as kids that hot air rises, but what nobody learns when you buy a house is that when warm air rises inside, it doesn't just stop at the ceiling. It keeps going. It looks for all of those gaps and cracks and openings through recessed lights, attic accesses, plumbing penetrations, wiring holes, all of these little cracks and crevices in the attic that people don't really think about. Your house, it is trying-- It-- Your-- So your house is constantly trying to exhale at the top, and when it exhales at the top, it has to inhale somewhere else, usually the basement, crawl space, rim joists. And suddenly, all the symptoms start connecting together: hot upstairs, humidity problems, drafts, dust, bugs, rooms that never feel balanced. These aren't random, unrelated problems. They're symptoms of the same pressure and air leakage issues happening throughout the house So one myth I hear constantly is old houses need to breathe. And I understand where that phrase came from, but uncontrolled air leakage, it's not healthy ventilation. That's just random leakage through dusty attics, damp crawl spaces, rim joist, wall cavities. Another big myth is that bigger HVACs-- bigger HVAC systems fix the problem. Sometimes bigger HVAC problems actually make the problem worse because now you cool the air in the summer too quickly. Because now in the summer, you're cooling your air too quickly without properly controlling humidity, so the house feels cold but clammy, which is exactly the kind of thing homeowners describe all the time without realizing humidity is the real issue. And honestly, windows are probably the most over-blamed component in any house. I've seen homeowners spend enormous amounts of money replacing windows while massive attic bypasses were still sitting there wide open After identifying the leakage pathways, we went through and systematically sealed the house. We sealed the attic floor. We took care of all those penetrations, all the problem areas. We also addressed the HVAC duct system, which was very leaky, and then we addressed the insulation improvements. And one of my favorite moments in every project is the test out, the blower door test, where we actually measure the results because suddenly the invisible becomes measurable. The house went from an extremely leaky house to roughly a thirty cent. The house went from extremely leaky. The house-- We were able to reduce the air leakage in this house by thirty-six percent. And what I always tell people is that it was in all the right places, which is a massive improvement. And what's really satisfying is when homeowners start noticing the changes almost immediately. Rooms feel calmer, temperatures stabilize, the HVAC system sounds less stressed. The house starts feeling quieter, more even, more controlled. And the important thing is none of this was magic. The house simply stopped fighting itself as aggressively. One thing I've learned after doing all of these audits is that houses are incredibly logical once you understand that the ru- the rule... Once you understand the rules by which they operate. They leave clues constantly. Comfort problems, they're not random. There's usually a reason for it. The challenge is that most homeowners are trying to solve symptoms without ever being shown the underlying causes. And honestly, I think that's why building science feels so empowering once people finally understand it. Because suddenly the house stops feeling mysterious. You start realizing, oh, that's why this room is always hot. Oh, that's why I feel cold down here in the basement. That's why the basement smells musty, and that's why the HVAC is running all the time. The house is telling a story. You just have to know how to listen to it So if your house feels uncomfortable, if certain rooms never feel right, your HVAC system seems to run constantly, if you've spent money and still feel frustrated, you're definitely not alone. And that's exactly why I made this podcast, because the more homeowners understand how their houses actually work, the easier it's gonna become to make smart decisions instead of expensive guesses. And in future episodes, I'm gonna keep breaking down these real-- these story... I'm gonna-- And in future episodes, I'm gonna keep breaking down some of these real-world stories one house at a time and try to give you insights, and maybe there's some overlap with some house, some of the things going on in your house so that you can get cued in and figure out how to fix it.